Con: Defensive Fundamentals
The New York Knicks need a point guard who can defend at a high level, which was the primary reason for the selection of Frank Ntilikina at No. 8 overall in the 2017 NBA Draft. In signing Shelvin Mack, however, the Knicks would be taking a slight step backwards.
Although Mack’s level of intensity may be commendable, his execution on the defensive end of the floor leaves something to be desired.
It’s necessary to acknowledge that Mack is respected as a player whose effort and intensity won’t be questioned on defense. Effort is ideal, but it’s not the only aspect of defensive execution that’s necessary for consistency.
Tenacity would be appealing to a Knicks team that lacked anything close to a consistent level of energy or intensity in 2016-17, but execution is equally as important.
True as that may be, Mack gets too high on defense and often lacks the balance necessary to stay in front of his man. He may be a pest on the defensive end of the floor, but players with mental fortitude will still find ways to exploit his stance.
Mack’s defensive inconsistencies can be coached, but if Quin Snyder couldn’t help him, it’s fair to question if any coach can.